Yes, but the answer is less obvious than you might think.
Samuel Scheffler is a professor of philosophy and law at New York University and the author, most recently, of “Why Worry About Future Generations?”
It is impossible to ignore the stark disparities of income and wealth that prevail in this country, and a great many of us are troubled by this state of affairs.
But is economic inequality really what bothers us? An influential essay published in 1987 by the philosopher Harry Frankfurt suggests that we have misidentified the problem. Professor Frankfurt argued that it does not matter whether some people have less than others. What matters is that some people do not have enough. They lack adequate income, have little or no wealth and do not enjoy decent housing, health care or education. If even the worst-off people had enough resources to lead good and fulfilling lives, then the fact that others had still greater resources would not be troubling.
When some people don’t have enough and others have vastly more than they need, it is easy to conclude that the problem is one of inequality. But this, according to Professor Frankfurt, is a mistake. The problem isn’t inequality as such. It’s the poverty and deprivation suffered by those who have least.
Professor Frankfurt’s essay didn’t persuade all his fellow philosophers, many of whom remained egalitarians. But his challenge continued to resonate and, in 2015,even as concerns about economic inequality were growing in many corners of society, he published a short book in which he reaffirmed his position.
And Professor Frankfurt, it seems, has a point. Those in the top 10 percent of America’s economic distribution are in a very comfortable position. Those in the top 1 percent are in an even more comfortable position than those in the other 9 percent. But few people find this kind of inequality troubling. Inequality bothers us most, it seems, only when some are very rich and others are very poor.
Even when the worst-off people are very poor, moreover, it wouldn’t be an improvement to reduce everyone else to their level. Equality would then prevail, but equal misery is hardly an ideal worth striving for.
So perhaps we shouldn’t object to economic inequality as such. Instead, we should just try to improve the position of those who have least. We should work to eliminate poverty, hunger, bad schools, substandard housing and inadequate medical care. But we shouldn’t make the elimination of inequality our aim.
Is this the correct conclusion? I think not. Economic inequality matters a great deal whether or not it matters “as such.”
Start by considering two points that Professor Frankfurt himself would accept. First, to succeed in eliminating poverty and securing decent conditions of life for all Americans would require raising taxes on the rich significantly. Although the ultimate purpose would not be to reduce inequality, the indirect effect would be to do just that. So even if inequality as such is not the problem, reducing inequality is almost certainly part of the solution.
Second, even if economic inequality is not a problem in and of itself, it can still have bad effects. Great disparities of income and wealth, of the kind we see in the United States today, can have damaging effects even when nobody is badly off in absolute terms. For example, the wealthiest may be able to exert a disproportionate share of political influence and to shape society in conformity with their interests. They may be able to make the law work for them rather than for everyone, and so undermine the rule of law. Enough economic inequality can transform a democracy into a plutocracy, a society ruled by the rich.
Large inequalities of inherited wealth can be particularly damaging, creating, in effect, an economic caste system that inhibits social mobility and undercuts equality of opportunity.
Extreme inequality can also have subtler and more insidious effects, which are especially pronounced when those who have the least are also poor and lack adequate resources, but which may persist even if everyone has enough. The rich may persuade themselves that they fully deserve their enormous wealth and develop attitudes of entitlement and privilege. Those who have less may develop feelings of inferiority and deference, on the one hand, and hostility and resentment on the other. In this way, extreme inequality can distort people’s view of themselves and compromise their relations with one another.
This brings us to a more fundamental point. The great political philosopher John Rawls thought that a liberal society should conceive of itself as a fair system of cooperation among free and equal people. Often, it seems, we do like to think of ourselves that way. We know that our society has always been blighted by grave injustices, beginning with the great moral catastrophe of slavery, but we aspire to create a society of equals, and we are proud of the steps we have taken toward that ideal.
But extreme inequality makes a mockery of our aspiration. In a society marked by the spectacular inequalities of income and wealth that have emerged in the United States in the past few decades, there is no meaningful sense in which all citizens, rich and poor alike, can nevertheless relate to one another on an equal footing. Even if poverty were eliminated and everyone had enough resources to lead a decent life, that would not by itself transform American citizenship into a relationship among equals. There is a limit to the degree of economic inequality that is compatible with the ideal of a society of equals and, although there is room for disagreement about where exactly the limit lies, it is clear that we have long since exceeded it.
If extreme economic inequality undermines the ideal of a society of equals, then is that merely one of its bad effects, like its corrupting influence on the political process? Or, instead, is that simply what it is for economic inequality to matter as such?
For practical purposes, it doesn’t make much difference which answer we give. In either case, the imperative that Professor Frankfurt identified — the imperative to ensure that all citizens have enough resources to lead decent lives — is of the utmost importance. It is appalling that so many people in a society as wealthy as ours continue to lack adequate housing, nutrition, medical care and education, and do not enjoy the full benefits of the rule of law. But addressing Professor Frankfurt’s imperative is not enough. Extreme economic inequality, whether it matters as such or “merely” for its effects, is pernicious. It threatens to transform us from a democracy into a plutocracy, and it makes a mockery of the ideal of equal citizenship.
If, as they say, every crisis is an opportunity, then America today is truly the land of opportunity. Of the many opportunities with which our current crises have presented us, one of the most basic is the opportunity to rethink our conception of ourselves as a society. Going forward, we must decide whether we wish to constitute ourselves as a genuine society of equals or, alternatively, whether we are content to have our relations with one another structured by an increasingly stark and unforgiving economic and social hierarchy.
… [Trackback]
[…] Read More Info here to that Topic: newscencord.org/is-economic-inequality-really-a-problem/ […]
… [Trackback]
[…] Info on that Topic: newscencord.org/is-economic-inequality-really-a-problem/ […]
… [Trackback]
[…] Read More on to that Topic: newscencord.org/is-economic-inequality-really-a-problem/ […]
… [Trackback]
[…] Here you can find 10242 additional Information to that Topic: newscencord.org/is-economic-inequality-really-a-problem/ […]
… [Trackback]
[…] Find More here to that Topic: newscencord.org/is-economic-inequality-really-a-problem/ […]
… [Trackback]
[…] There you can find 54593 additional Information on that Topic: newscencord.org/is-economic-inequality-really-a-problem/ […]
… [Trackback]
[…] Find More to that Topic: newscencord.org/is-economic-inequality-really-a-problem/ […]
… [Trackback]
[…] Find More on to that Topic: newscencord.org/is-economic-inequality-really-a-problem/ […]
… [Trackback]
[…] Read More here to that Topic: newscencord.org/is-economic-inequality-really-a-problem/ […]
… [Trackback]
[…] There you will find 37264 additional Information to that Topic: newscencord.org/is-economic-inequality-really-a-problem/ […]
… [Trackback]
[…] Find More Information here on that Topic: newscencord.org/is-economic-inequality-really-a-problem/ […]
… [Trackback]
[…] Read More Info here to that Topic: newscencord.org/is-economic-inequality-really-a-problem/ […]
… [Trackback]
[…] Find More on to that Topic: newscencord.org/is-economic-inequality-really-a-problem/ […]
… [Trackback]
[…] Read More on to that Topic: newscencord.org/is-economic-inequality-really-a-problem/ […]
… [Trackback]
[…] There you can find 75046 additional Info to that Topic: newscencord.org/is-economic-inequality-really-a-problem/ […]
I know this web site provides quality depending
articles or reviews and additional stuff, is there any other site
which presents such data in quality?
Look into my homepage – finance attorney
Good day! I know this is kinda off topic but I was wondering which blog platform are you using for this site?
I’m getting sick and tired of WordPress because I’ve had problems with hackers and I’m looking at alternatives
for another platform. I would be fantastic if you could point me in the
direction of a good platform.
Here is my webpage Directory6.org
Hello there, You have done an excellent job.
I’ll certainly digg it and personally suggest to my friends.
I am sure they’ll be benefited from this website.
my blog – http://www.eliteservicesnetwork.com
Sweet blog! I found it while searching on Yahoo News. Do
you have any suggestions on how to get listed in Yahoo News?
I’ve been trying for a while but I never seem to get there!
Thanks
My web-site party strippers
Greetings! Very useful advice within this article!
It’s the little changes that make the greatest changes.
Thanks a lot for sharing!
my page :: southwestinjurylaw.com
Howdy! I know this is somewhat off topic but I was wondering which blog platform
are you using for this site? I’m getting sick and tired of WordPress because I’ve had problems with hackers and I’m looking at options for another
platform. I would be great if you could point me in the
direction of a good platform.
Also visit my page … Henrietta
… [Trackback]
[…] Read More here to that Topic: newscencord.org/is-economic-inequality-really-a-problem/ […]
If you desire to improve your familiarity only keep visiting this site and be updated with
the latest news update posted here.
my site – golf caddies for hire
Hello to every one, the contents existing at this web
page are truly awesome for people experience, well,
keep up the nice work fellows.
Here is my page … body treatment West Lake Village
Since the admin of this site is working, no hesitation very quickly it will be well-known, due to its quality contents.
my web blog – https://Free-Weblink.Com
Incredible story there. What occurred after? Take care!
My web-site: insurance claims lawyers
I know this web site presents quality based posts and extra information, is there any other web page
which offers these kinds of things in quality?
Feel free to surf to my blog: injury attornes
Thank you for sharing your thoughts. I really appreciate your efforts
and I am waiting for your further write ups thanks once
again.
Here is my page Jeannette
gay sex escape games https://cybersexgames.net/
play online casino for real money https://onlinecasinoad.com/
casino online for real money https://casinogamesmachines.com/
online casino sverige https://conline-casinos-hub.com/
zone online casino https://online2casino.com/
casino online streaming https://casinoonlinet.com/
uk online casino https://casinosonlinex.com/
macro calculator keto https://ketogenicdiets.net/
keto cookie recipes https://ketogendiet.net/
keto lasagna https://ketogenicdietinfo.com/
keto diets https://ketogendiets.com/
essay writing companies https://anenglishessay.com/
write my essay 4 me https://topessayswriter.com/
admission essay writing service https://yoursuperessay.com/
analysis essay writing https://howtowriteessaytips.com/
essay writing books https://checkyouressay.com/
dating older gay men tumblr https://gayprideusa.com/
gay dating portland https://gayfade.com/
critical thinking activity https://criticalthinkingbasics.com/
levels of critical thinking https://criticalthinkinginstitute.com/
definitions of critical thinking https://criticalthinking2020.net/
critical thinking training https://uncriticalthinking.com/
book title in essay https://choosevpn.net/
uchicago essay prompts https://topvpndeals.net/
how to cite a source in an essay https://tjvpn.net/
usc essay prompts https://thebestvpnpro.com/
how long is a short essay https://vpn4home.com/
what’s a narrative essay https://vpnshroud.com/
essay writing help https://vpn4torrents.com/
how to write an essay for a scholarship https://windowsvpns.com/
1jessica
indian gay chat https://bjsgaychatroom.info
gay dating hole https://gaypridee.com
gay dating professional bodybuilders https://gay-buddies.com
gay dating a macho https://gayprideusa.com
mature gay men dating https://speedgaydate.com
international gay dating website https://gayfade.com
hiv negative dating an hiv positive gay man https://gaysugardaddydatingsites.com
gay daddies free chat https://bjsgaychatroom.info/
gay dating free https://gaypridee.com/
google zoom gay chat room https://gaytgpost.com/
chat avenue gay chat room https://gay-buddies.com/
gay men dating sites https://speedgaydate.com/
deal or no deal slots https://2-free-slots.com/
free fun slots no download https://freeonlneslotmachine.com/
scatter slots by murka https://candylandslotmachine.com/
ruby slots https://pennyslotmachines.org/
konami slots download https://slotmachinesworld.com/
free igt slots https://slotmachinesforum.net/
hit it rich slots https://slot-machine-sale.com/
my konami slots https://beat-slot-machines.com/
caesars free slots online https://download-slot-machines.com/
pompeii slots https://411slotmachine.com/
online slots https://www-slotmachines.com/
free slots games for fun https://slotmachinegameinfo.com/
online cheap dissertation help https://dissertations-writing.org/
help with dissertation topic https://helpon-doctoral-dissertations.net/
We’re a group of volunteers and starting a new scheme in our community.
Your web site offered us with valuable info to work on. You have done a
formidable job and our whole community will
be thankful to you.
Here is my blog – best Cannabis Dispensary
Thank you, I have just been searching for information about this subject for
a long time and yours is the best I have discovered so far.
But, what in regards to the bottom line? Are you positive in regards
to the source?
Visit my web blog … Tonja
Hello, all is going sound here and ofcourse every one is sharing data, that’s really fine, keep
up writing.
My website: cannabis
cheap genuine viagra online sildenafil 20 mg price comparison